Gay Religion, Eds. Scott Thumma and Edward R. Gray
“A Religion of One’s Own: Gender and LGBT Religiosities” (Melissa M. Wilcox)
“Shades of Grey or Back to Nature? The Enduring Qualities of Ex-Gay Ministries” (Christy M. Ponticelli)
“Negotiating a Religious Identity: The Case of the Gay Evangelical” (Scott Thumma)
A few weeks ago, I purchased Gay Religion and promised to write more about the text as I read through it. I’ve now read three of the articles, skimmed through the titles and opening paragraphs of the others, and would recommend this as a classroom textbook. Unless you’re very interested in statistically based sociological analysis of the LGBT culture, I would suggest that you forgo this book and pick up something more accessible and readable. However, this would make an excellent beginning reader in a sociology or religious studies classroom, as well as a thorough resource for gay and lesbian writers, gay-friendly parishes/congregations, and non-profit organizations working in these overlapping areas.
I chose the three essays above because they most closely tracked with my own personal experience, giving me a better yardstick for evaluation then the essays on gay male culture. Ponticelli’s article on ex-gay ministries arises from her experience “undercover” at the 1992 Exodus conference and subsequent months in a Northern California ex-gay ministry. She claims that her purpose is not to evaluate whether these ministries are appropriate or successful, but to understand their appeal. This is a laudable intention, to hear before critiquing, and to give the benefit of doubt to those one might consider “enemies” of LGBT persons. Unfortunately, I wonder, as she seems to in her conclusion, whether this is even possible.
Recent Comments